PDA

View Full Version : More Tales from the Ottawa Valley Caves



Tom Falardeau
July 2nd, 2007, 08:42 PM
The Ottawa Sidemount Cave Divers got together again today for another foray into the dark and mysterious caves that wind their way under the Ottawa River "up the line". This time, the target was to be Three Island Cave.

The meet up "chez Jim" went flawlessly this week and we were at our destination, a nice little resort on the River, before 11AM. You see, unlike Gervais Cave, which is shore-diveable, you need a boat to reach one of the many resurgences of Three Island Cave, so named because (ta-da! :D) it snakes its way under three islands! Fortunately, that nice little resort I mentioned two seconds ago rents out aluminum boats big enough and with an engine powerful enough to take 4 divers, 8 cylinders and sundry equipment to their destination.

In no time flat, we were loaded (fully dressed in our drysuits, of course) and on our way upriver, with Jim at the helm. We'd done Three Island Cave last fall and found one of the entrances at the bottom of the river, a mere 20 ft from shore. Today, with my memory still working despite my age, I got us tied up right above that hole.

Diving from a small boat is where sidemount really comes in handy.... we climbed out into the shallows and helped each other get the tanks out of the boat and into the water, where we got kitted out.

Jim, as usual, was the first one down the hole and out of sight in the cave. Marie and I soon followed, sticking to the main line, while Marc was taking his time. The flow in the cave was moderate... until we hit the dogleg a couple of hundred feet in and dropped 10ft deeper. There it was fairly ripping due to another, nearby resurgence which is collapsed but still provides enough of an outlet for the water. The visibility was, Ottawa River style, limited to about 5ft. However, we were able to enjoy the fragile and wonderful limestone formations within that sight radius, competing for room with many fish, including a sturgeon of some size. After about half an hour, I got tired of pulling myself upflow and turned the dive. We were flying until we hit the dogleg - the main concern was not running into rock or each other at that speed. Coming out of the lower tunnel and around the bend, we managed to get out of the flow, and resumed our leisurely swim towards the exit, meeting Marc along the way. The way out took us about half the time spent going in, and soon enough, we saw the dim, blood red glow of the resurgence hole.

Once on the surface, Marie and I hung around our boat, taking a breather. Marc joined us shortly thereafter and we waited for Jim - so as to decide whether or not we would be moving to a different spot, or doing some resurgence hole hunting further upriver. Jim didn't join us all that soon and after a while, we began to walk & swim the riverbed, looking for other holes we knew to be there..... we didn't find out why Jim's dive was taking so long until later - after Marc and I had spent some time exploring a huge resurgence hole about 100ft from shore.

Jim, as seasoned Ottawa River cave explorer, had gone into the cave much deeper than the rest of us went, and even laid down about 70ft of new line in virgin cave! On the way back, he decided to do a trip down a side tunnel halfway between the dogleg and the entrance. We'd done that tunnel last fall and it is pleasant, gets progressively smaller and siltier, and is marked by an old cave line......... which broke under Jim's very eyes, when he was almost 100ft away from the mainline. Both ends vanished into the darkness, leaving Jim to carry out, for the first time in real life, the lost line drills we were taught during training. Training kicked in.

Jim remained stuck against the ceiling so as not to lose his orientation while he pulled out his safety spool. He found a small protrusion on the ceiling which would just suffice to tie in his spool. Now the rock in those caves is very fragile and breaks if you so much as look at it... and Jim had to make sure this one would hold while he found his way back. Once he was tied in, he made a 180 degree turn to face the direction he came and headed out, finding the mainline without many problems. Of course, once the safety spool comes out, the dive is over and once back at the mainline, Jim headed for the entrance and open water. His day of diving was done. Although the training had been ingrained enough to help him get out of a potentially life threatening situation without much more than a tight feeling in his gut, something like that pretty much kills the concentration you need to keep on diving that same day.

While this drama unfolded, Marc and I found the deep resurgence and looked for some permanent line. With the limited visibility and the sheer size of the hole in the bottom of the river, it got spooky fast. Marc didn't have a primary reel with him and headed back to shore after exploring the perimeter of the resurgence. I, on the other hand, had my primary reel, and I found a place to tie it in open water - as it turned out not on the most solid of rocks. Running my own line, I entered the cave going into the flow, did my secondary tie off and headed in. I spend a good 10-15 minutes looking for a permanent line, sweeping the width of the cave as I headed deeper in. Except for the visibility, it reminded me much of the front part of Devil's in Florida: large rocks, cracks, strong flow and lots of fish, including another sturgeon. I found a fragment of the old line, but eventually gave up, heading back out. Being alone in such a huge cave with very few visual points of reference and no permanent line, I will confess to having gotten a tad spooked. I do prefer the tighter tunnels.

Reeling in my line, I soon found my secondary tie off solid and within sight of the dull red glow of the hole, but my primary tie off had eaten through the rock! It was nearly totally loose - a good lesson about the geology around there, and the importance of a solid secondary tie off in the cavern zone (such as it is around here). Next time, I will have to search further afield for some granite to tie on, rather than the limestone - which is much more fragile here than in Florida, it seems.

I found my three companions hanging around the boat, waiting for me as I swam back to shore on the surface, and that's when I heard about Jim's adventures. No one was up for another dive (we had plenty of breathing gas left, however) and thus we headed back to the dock in our rented boat, but not before noting the landmarks and bearings that would allow us to find that mid-river hole again next time.

Back on shore, we spent some time studying the map, and clearly Marc had found several more resurgence holes further upstream from the huge one I explored. Three Island Cave remains fertile ground for exploration, and if we so desire, ground for laying permanent line for future explorers. We will surely be back this summer - perhaps even with our scooters so we can more easily access those cave entrances distant from shore. The current in the Ottawa River is nothing to sneeze at (and sneezing in one's mask is unpleasant, but that's another story).

Today's expedition was definitely more "interesting" than last Sunday's. We know this cave less than Gervais, and it reminded us that cave diving isn't for the faint of heart - after all, it is considered an extreme sport even for divers. It is comforting, however, to know that training will out in a problematic situation.

As they say on TV, don't try this at home, kids.

Dale
July 2nd, 2007, 10:03 PM
I could have never gotten Jim to tell me that many details - thanks.

I enjoy reading your reports, =).

Check-out dives this weekend! I'm excited.

Neil
July 2nd, 2007, 10:58 PM
Thanks for the exciting cave diving story!

In Florida they taught us to let some "more experienced" cave diver's know if the permanent line is broken and you use your safety spool to find your way out. How does that work up here, where your group seems to be the main people actively diving and exploring these caves? Is this like the wild west of cave diving?

Tom Falardeau
July 2nd, 2007, 11:12 PM
Thanks for the exciting cave diving story!

In Florida they taught us to let some "more experienced" cave diver's know if the permanent line is broken and you use your safety spool to find your way out. How does that work up here, where your group seems to be the main people actively diving and exploring these caves? Is this like the wild west of cave diving?

Down in God's Country, there are line committtees for a lot of the caves - volunteers who take care of keeping the permanent lines in good repair. Up here, it's pretty much the wild west. The lines were placed by the people who did the original mapping about a decade and a half ago, and since these caves aren't regularly dove, there's pretty much no one to take care of them. So far, Jim has done a number of repairs as he happens on messy spots, mainly to keep it safe for us - we have no idea who else is diving those caves, 'cause we're the only ones talking about it openly. The lines around here are riskier than in Florida, and it's something of which we are well aware. Some spots, like the tunnel from the deep resurgence need an entirely new line, and Jim says that where that tunnel joins the mainline under the island is also a mess, so it's a moot point as to whether we'd expend the money, time and effort to reline it - may as well just use our primary reel for our forays and stay within the limits of our non-permanent line for safety.

JimC
July 3rd, 2007, 10:53 AM
Its good to know that all that quality training I paid for was worth the money. Its kinda actually a good experienced to have gone though. Not only did I prove that training is valuable but I also proved that I can remain calm and think though one of the more serious problems that can happen to you in a silty, 5 foot vis cave. I mean, I have lost my primary light a number of times, but thats nothing. In good vis cave like Florida, the line becomes a navigational aid to referencing the cave visually. In tanic, silty crap its much harder to do that and the line becomes more and more important.

It also drove the point home that visual cave referencing is probably even more important due to the vis. Just like in Florida, you should be diving the cave first, the line second. Heck, everything becomes more important as vis goes down. I think this experience will likely just cause me to raise the level of my game just that much higher. Mostly because I know if you cave dive long enough, shit will happen. When it does you better damn well be prepared to solve it.

P.S. Looks like I am going to sneak off for a nice easy Friday night cave dive just to get my legs back under me. The usual suspects are all invited, planning to leave my place around 4pm.

Tom Falardeau
July 3rd, 2007, 11:23 AM
This kind of experience does hammer home the fact that the caves up here are more challenging and more dangerous by a wide margin than the Florida tourist caves, and stuff you can get away with down there can kill you up here. For instance, in Florida, you can often see the glow of the cavern zone up to a 100 ft or more away - a good navigational aid. Here, you'll see the red glow of the opening literally 4-5ft ahead, no more. In clear water caves, you can plan on working as a team, and you'll see your buddy's light from quite a distance - very reassuring for one thing. Up here, I literally cannot see my buddy's 21wHID ahead of me, even though her fins are in my face. So even if I'm diving with my wife, we are both effectively alone and have to be utterly and completely self-sufficient and ready to save our own lives if needed. It requires a complete mind-shift from what we've been taught all our diving careers. I don't know if any training can prepare you for this kind of challenge - probably only progressively building experience (and this includes diving solo - being equipped and mentally ready to sive solo - no way to get around that need) in more challenging spots in the tourist caves, where mistakes can be corrected more easily, followed by easy, short dives in our caves to get acclimatized to the environment and to develop your mindset to be more ready to deal with being alone, in low or no viz.

edit: I just re-read what I wrote above and in the clear light of day on a Tuesday morning, I'm wondering *why* we do this...... it's kind of insane, no?

Neil
July 3rd, 2007, 12:37 PM
What was the area like where the line broke? How hard was it to find the line again? I bet it wasn't a small phreatic tube with two obvious directions to easily guide you out?



Its good to know that all that quality training I paid for was worth the money. Its kinda actually a good experienced to have gone though. Not only did I prove that training is valuable but I also proved that I can remain calm and think though one of the more serious problems that can happen to you in a silty, 5 foot vis cave. I mean, I have lost my primary light a number of times, but thats nothing. In good vis cave like Florida, the line becomes a navigational aid to referencing the cave visually. In tanic, silty crap its much harder to do that and the line becomes more and more important.

It also drove the point home that visual cave referencing is probably even more important due to the vis. Just like in Florida, you should be diving the cave first, the line second. Heck, everything becomes more important as vis goes down. I think this experience will likely just cause me to raise the level of my game just that much higher. Mostly because I know if you cave dive long enough, shit will happen. When it does you better damn well be prepared to solve it.

P.S. Looks like I am going to sneak off for a nice easy Friday night cave dive just to get my legs back under me. The usual suspects are all invited, planning to leave my place around 4pm.

JimC
July 3rd, 2007, 01:36 PM
With the vis in there, even a small cave is easy to swim circles in. So nothing was obvious. But, it easy rather easy to find the 'gold' line again. If you pay attention and get a good mental image of where you are, what you need to do becomes straight forward. For me, that meant following the left wall until it got big, then sweeping right along the floor until I hit the main line.

Neil
July 3rd, 2007, 02:41 PM
That sounds scary. If you can only see a couple of feet, finding the string would be a lot harder :(
I don't think I want to dive low viz caves any time soon

With the vis in there, even a small cave is easy to swim circles in. So nothing was obvious. But, it easy rather easy to find the 'gold' line again. If you pay attention and get a good mental image of where you are, what you need to do becomes straight forward. For me, that meant following the left wall until it got big, then sweeping right along the floor until I hit the main line.

owlbill
July 3rd, 2007, 02:57 PM
If you guys want to run new permanent lines in there, let me know and I will see what our rope supplier has that might do the trick.

JimC
July 3rd, 2007, 03:15 PM
A bunch of 36# for the small/out of flow stuff and I'd think 3/4 inch for the big/flow stuff if I were to reline it. Mind you a few hundred feet of 3/4 inch would get expensive - let alone finding the time to put it in.

Neil
July 5th, 2007, 03:59 PM
Is Burton's going to start offering ottawa river cave tours to certified cave divers?

Edit: You could even teach a PADI cavern cert and just take the new cavern divers into the zone where you can see the red glow ;)

Tom Falardeau
July 5th, 2007, 04:51 PM
Is Burton's going to start offering ottawa river cave tours to certified cave divers?

Edit: You could even teach a PADI cavern cert and just take the new cavern divers into the zone where you can see the red glow ;)

Trolling again, sunshine? ;)

It ain't the kind of environment you "tour", so the answer is no. Most certified cave divers have no business in a place like that. And there are minimum starting visibility standards for cavern/cave training - this ain't it.

owlbill
July 5th, 2007, 06:46 PM
A bunch of 36# for the small/out of flow stuff and I'd think 3/4 inch for the big/flow stuff if I were to reline it. Mind you a few hundred feet of 3/4 inch would get expensive - let alone finding the time to put it in.

If you let me know exactly what type of rope/cord you need (material, braid type etc.), I will check pricing. Can likely get custom colours done too. I asked Marc to try to find out what the "gold line" is that is used in Florida just for comparison. I could also ask our supplier what they recommend for that type of environment.

JimC
July 5th, 2007, 08:12 PM
Goldline is static nylon kernmantle. I think its about 1/8th inch. Mind you, some caves have just regular nylon double braid.. it his however supposed to be kernmantle.

I am sure anything from 3/8 to 3/4 inch double braid nylon would be sufficient for another 10 years in there. 3/8 inch static nylon kernmantle would work too, and I bet my Jumar would work on it. LOL. To bad kernmantle rope like that is somewhere in the $0.70 per foot range.

All the small/out of flow stuff could be done in #36 nylon braid (wreck line) and last for well over a decade. Heck most if it is 15 years old and #18 exploration line still.

marc g
July 5th, 2007, 10:44 PM
The goldline in most of the Florida caves is a little less than a 1/4 inch. 1/8 woould too small.

owlbill
July 6th, 2007, 11:33 AM
I have a call in to our supplier about a 3/16 static polyester kernmantle, tonnes of colours to shose from, including some neon. 600 and 1200 foot spools available.

The #36 line we could get through Salvo or Dive Rite easy enough.

owlbill
July 6th, 2007, 12:11 PM
Ok, I got pricing for a the following:


"Manufactured on a 32 carrier Kermantle braider these industrial climbing and decent ropes are static. The static characteristic is achieved by manufacturing the core of the rope with twisted polyester strands."

PM me if you want but it is way way less than $0.70 per foot.